Human noses: Quantum smelling devices
Technology has given mankind a machine alternative that bests every sense except one — smell. Current theories have been unable to account for our ability to perceive a seemingly infinite variety of new smells from a limited repertoire of receptors. If a chemist synthesizes a new compound never seen before on Earth, and our olfactory system can detect it, our brains vividly manufacture a completely new experience for it. One man, a perfumer and biophysicist named Luca Turin, has over the last two decades pieced together a highly-contested theory that seeks to explain how odors are detected and transduced — converted from molecules into neural spikes. This week he published incontrovertible evidence that may silence his many critics once and for all.
Throughout history, the acceptance of new theories has occurred not through the conversion of its detractors, but because eventually they die. New insight frequently transmutes the main argument against a new theory into its most powerful piece of evidence. Such is the case with a particular molecule known as carvone. As shown in the picture to the right, carvone comes in two enantiomers — in other words, flavors — that are mirror images of each other. Inexplicably, one enantiomer — the R- form — smells of spearmint, while the S- form smells of caraway or dill.
The traditional lock and key theory of smell holds that odorants bind into matched receptor pockets that detect shapes. This theory works fine for carvone so long as there are different receptors for each version. The main limitation of the lock and key concept is that there are many examples where molecules with completely different shapes smell similarly. For example, borane, which lacks any sulfur bonds, still has the rotten egg smell normally associated to those bonds. It turns out that borane has similar peaks in its infrared (IR) or vibrational spectrum that overlap those of sulfur bonds. Turin maintains that when an odorant binds into the right pocket, electrons can tunnel through it in a way that depends on the frequency at which the molecule intrinsically vibrates. The entire vibrational spectrum would be divided up with each receptor commanding a small chuck of it. In this interpretation, the nose becomes more-or-less a chemical spectroscope.
The problem carvone presents to Turin’s theory is that although the mirror images smell different, they possess identical IR spectrums. In dramatic counterpoint to this seeming roadblock, Turin added butanol to a sample of dill carvone and made it smell like spearmint. Butanol has the same kind of bond found in carvone but it is small enough to slip into receptor pockets along with it. The critics shifted gears by demonstrating that the small molecule acetophenone smells the same to humans even when its vibrational spectrum is altered by substituting some of its hydrogens with heavier deuterium atoms. This substitution causes the bonds of the molecule to oscillate more slowly, effectively altering the global undulation of the entire molecule and the ability of electrons to tunnel through it. Turin had already showed in Drosophila, the fruit fly, that the deuterated forms of acetophenone could be discriminated at least behaviorally, but that is just not as experimentally convincing as a human directly reporting what they smell.
Turin’s masterstroke, published this week in Plos One, demonstrates that one grenade does not bring down the whole fort. Turin hypothesized that a larger molecule like a musk, with more points that could be deuterated, would be more detectable to humans. Musk molecules are about as large as you can get as far as being able to fit inside olfactory receptors. At a weight of nearly 300Da (daltons), most of them can hardly be considered volatile and tend to reside on the ground or stick to objects like trees. Just a couple molecules of this potent and expensive stuff is, at least for the deer or wild boar, plenty enough to make their world go round.
To extricate the various and subtle forms of these compounds from the vessel in which they were brewed, Turin uses a gas chromatograph. To avoid any contamination or degradation of the sample, the odorants are often consumed directly from the exit port of the machine as quickly as possible. The expert testers in the study descriptively assessed the undeuterated samples as familiarly pungent and musky, while all the vibrationally modified samples took on new character captured only through words like nutty, roasted, oily metallic and harsh.
Even these distinctions still have an air of subjectivity and are often only made intelligible by those possessing both a keen nose and acute descriptive power. As old theory yields to hard won data, machine sensing will be the immediate benefactor, while, for us, the artificial nose, enhanced perception, and greater understanding of how we internally package the larger realities of our sensory landscape may soon follow. Fully decoding this mysterious prowess remains the final frontier of sensory science. The genome is littered with countless defunct receptor proteins cast aside in recent evolution along with our atrophied primate olfactory bulbs. The olfactory organ is a privileged area of the brain where new neurons continually migrate and interconnect making it an attractive region for the study of regeneration. Eventual redeployment of the lost intuitions of the canine through proper technology will enrich our human experience in ways we can only now imagine.
Now read: Do humans dream of android prostitutes?
Research paper: doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0055780 – “Molecular Vibration-Sensing Component in Human Olfaction”
- Cuffie Quantum EL-01 di Tonino Lamborghini, primo contatto
- MIT upgrades human hand with two extra robot fingers. But why stop there?
- WiTricity’s wireless charging technology is coming soon to mobile devices and electric cars
- Microsoft shakes things up yet again, will now focus on mobile and cloud – not devices and services
- The human brain’s remarkably low power consumption, and how computers might mimic its efficiency
- Foxconn is attempting to replace its human workers with thousands of robots
- Scientists discover the on-off switch for human consciousness deep within the brain
- Ubiquiti Networks Launches mFi In-Wall Manageable Devices
- Inside the First Android Wear Devices: LG G Watch & Samsung Gear Live Teardown
- Focus Fusion: Has cheap, clean Earth-saving fusion power been right under our noses all along?